Debunking the Maternal Instinct Myth: Why Parenting Skills Are Learned, Not Innate
October 2, 2024
As Physician moms, we're often expected to have it all together. We're supposed to seamlessly transition from delivering babies or treating patients to nurturing our own children with an innate wisdom that society calls "maternal instinct." But what if I told you that this concept of maternal instinct is largely a myth?
The Truth About Instinct
Let's start by defining what instinct really is. Instinct refers to behaviors that are hardwired into our nervous system - things that help us survive and reproduce. The urge to protect our child from harm? That's instinct. Knowing how to change a diaper or soothe a crying baby? That's learned behavior.
The Role of Socialization
From a young age, many of us are socialized to be caregivers. We're given baby dolls, encouraged to babysit, and often exposed to childcare through younger siblings or cousins. This early exposure and education shape our abilities as parents far more than any innate "instinct."
The Pressure of the Myth
Believing in the myth of maternal instinct can create unnecessary pressure and guilt. If you don't immediately bond with your baby or struggle with certain aspects of parenting, you might feel like you're failing or that something is wrong with you. But the truth is, everyone has a learning curve when it comes to parenting.
Impact on Partners
This myth doesn't just affect mothers. It also gives partners, especially fathers, an excuse to be less involved in childcare. After all, if mothers have this magical instinct, why should fathers need to learn these skills?
Reframing Parenting as a Learned Skill
By recognizing that parenting skills are learned, not innate, we can:
Relieve guilt and pressure on new parents
Encourage all parents to actively learn and participate in childcare
Create more realistic expectations for the parenting journey
Promote equality in parenting responsibilities
The Way Forward
Instead of relying on the myth of maternal instinct, let's focus on education and support for all parents. This means:
Providing comprehensive parenting education for all genders
Normalizing the learning curve of parenthood
Encouraging partners to be equally involved in childcare
Supporting each other through the challenges of parenting
Remember, doc, you weren't born knowing how to be a Physician - you learned. Parenting is no different. It's a skill that we develop over time, with practice and patience. So give yourself grace, seek out resources when you need them, and remember that struggling doesn't make you a bad parent - it makes you human.
Let's shed these antiquated ideas about motherhood and create a more realistic, supportive environment for all parents. Because at the end of the day, what our children need most isn't a parent with perfect "instincts," but one who loves them and is committed to learning and growing alongside them.
Don’t miss an episode!
Follow the podcast on Buzzsprout, Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
